New Castle's highest-rated bathtub replacement companies

6 bathtub replacement businesses made the cut for New Castle on Google Maps, ranked by rating rather than sorted by trade. That's a different list than our usual plumbers-first grouping, because a Google listing doesn't carry a trade classification the way a state file does. Confirm who's actually doing the plumbing connections before you book anyone on this list.

Google Maps ratings checked · How we rank

82%of homes built before 1980

Housing age in New Castle

Homes in New Castle typically date to 1956.

A tub installed around then has usually outlasted at least one owner already, on the 1956 construction alone.

That is the kind of tub New Castle's pros are used to pulling out.

Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, table-based Summary File (2024 table-based Summary File) (2024 table-based Summary File).

Bathtub replacement in New Castle, IN, ranked by Google rating

Sorted by a star rating that leans on review volume instead of split by trade; it doesn't tell you which license, if any, covers the plumbing part of the job.

  1. Duty Calls Plumbing

    Bathroom remodeler

    Google rating
    4.9 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    460
    Area
    New Castle 47362
    Google reviews
  2. Total Construction and Remodeling Inc.

    General contractor

    Google rating
    5.0 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    8
    Area
    Not listed
    Google reviews
  3. Neal's Custom Exterior

    General contractor

    Google rating
    4.4 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    47
    Area
    New Castle 47362
    Google reviews
  4. R.E. Construction

    Contractor

    Google rating
    4.0 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    3
    Area
    New Castle 47362
    Google reviews
  5. Regal Roofing & Construction

    Roofing contractor

    Google rating
    3.6 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    24
    Area
    New Castle 47362
    Google reviews
  6. M L Taylor Construction

    Bathroom remodeler

    Google rating
    3.6 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    29
    Area
    New Castle 47362
    Google reviews

Questions before you swap a tub

  1. Is this a like-for-like swap, or does the drain move, and does that change whether we need a permit?
  2. Which of your licenses covers this: plumbing, or a remodeling license, or both?
  3. What does the new tub weigh, and does the floor underneath need any reinforcement?
  4. Was this house built before 1978, and if so, how are you handling any painted surfaces you disturb?
  5. Are you reusing the existing drain and overflow, or replacing that hardware too?
  6. What is the real difference in your price between refinishing, a liner, and a full replacement?

More on Indiana →

More Indiana tub replacement pros

All cities in Indiana →