Who's top-rated for bathtub replacement in Sayville

Sayville gets a ranked list of 6 bathtub replacement companies here, pulled from Google Maps rather than a trade-sorted license file. Homes in Sayville typically date to 1966, old enough that the tub coming out is rarely the first one that bathroom has seen. None of these companies has been checked for a plumbing license; that question is still yours to ask.

Google Maps ratings checked · How we rank

72%of homes built before 1980

Housing age in Sayville

Homes built before 1980 make up 72% of the housing in Sayville.

Cast iron was the default tub material for most of that era in Sayville, part of why so many older bathrooms still have one.

Our materials guide covers what a cast iron tub weighs before Sayville homeowners plan its replacement.

Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, table-based Summary File (2024 table-based Summary File) (2024 table-based Summary File).

Bathtub replacement in Sayville, NY, ranked by Google rating

Sorted by a star rating that leans on review volume instead of split by trade; it doesn't tell you which license, if any, covers the plumbing part of the job.

  1. Long Island Home Advisors

    Bathroom remodeler

    Google rating
    5.0 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    322
    Area
    Bayport 11705
    Google reviews
  2. Accessible Remodeling

    Bathroom remodeler

    Google rating
    4.9 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    61
    Area
    Oakdale 11769
    Google reviews
  3. Bath Planet of Metro NY

    Bathroom remodeler

    Google rating
    5.0 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    33
    Area
    Holbrook 11741
    Google reviews
  4. Reliable Home Remodeling

    Contractor

    Google rating
    4.8 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    60
    Area
    Bayport 11705
    Google reviews
  5. Alan S Gross Plumbing & Heating

    Plumber

    Google rating
    4.4 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    29
    Area
    Sayville 11782
    Google reviews
  6. Sayville Custom Mirrors Inc

    Contractor

    Google rating
    3.8 out of 5 on Google
    Reviews
    23
    Area
    Sayville 11782
    Google reviews

Questions before you swap a tub

  1. Is this a like-for-like swap, or does the drain move, and does that change whether we need a permit?
  2. Which of your licenses covers this: plumbing, or a remodeling license, or both?
  3. What does the new tub weigh, and does the floor underneath need any reinforcement?
  4. Was this house built before 1978, and if so, how are you handling any painted surfaces you disturb?
  5. Are you reusing the existing drain and overflow, or replacing that hardware too?
  6. What is the real difference in your price between refinishing, a liner, and a full replacement?

More on New York →

More New York tub replacement pros

All cities in New York →